“The Lie”
|
<< MySite Home | |
|
By the Grace of G-d Copyright © 2009 Nathaniel Segal |
|
Darius the Great's Foundation Inscription at Behistun; engraved in the Old Persian, Akkadian, and Elamite languages after his third regnal year. Behistun (also Bisitun, Bisutun, or Bisotun), near the town of Jeyhounabad in western Iran, is on a cliff along the road between today's Hamadān and Kermānshāh [former name Bakhtaran], Iran. Darius's inscriptions surround a relief that represents his defeat of rebels and A representation of the god, Ahura Mazda, hovers above the entire scene. Darius made the inscription and relief inaccessible by removing the mountainside below the relief to make sure that "liars" would not alter his account. See the beginning of the fourth column – from Jona Lendering or from Joseph H. Peterson – for Darius's account of his first year as Great King. Also see the beginning of the fourth column on this web site. |
||
Photo above: © Ab Langereis, Livius.org. Used with permission †. |
Darius's Behistun Inscription – in the Old Persian cuneiform alphabet which Darius calls the Aryan script. Column 1, lines 1-15, sketched by Fr. Spiegel (1881). Picture from Wikipedia † |
Translations of Column 4 |
The Lie - draugâ
The text of column 4 serves as evidence that Darius the Great was a usurper. Earlier, Darius had claimed in column 1, section 10 (1.26-35) and onward, that:
"This is what was done by me after I became king. A son of Cyrus, Cambyses by name, of our family – he was king here; of that Cambyses there was a brother, Bardiya [Smerdis] by name, having the same mother and the same father as Cambyses. Afterwards, Cambyses slew that Bardiya. When Cambyses slew Bardiya, it did not become known to the people that Bardiya had been slain. Afterwards, Cambyses went to Egypt. When Cambyses had gone off to Egypt, after that the people became evil. After that the Lie waxed great in the country, both in Persia and in Medîa * and in the other provinces." (Adapted from Peterson) |
Darius's Grandiosity"I am Darius the Great King, King of Kings, King in Persia, king of countries . . . an Achaemenian" (column 1, line 1). Declaration of Good Kingship
|
Comparisons |
||
The Cyrus Cylinder | The Behistun Inscription | |
---|---|---|
Work in progress | Cambyses allegedly slew Bardiya, his brother. Therefore, Cambyses had forfeited his claim to the throne. |
|
"The Lie waxed great in the country." | ||
Gaumata rose up and he lied to the people, saying: "I am Bardiya, the son of Cyrus, brother of Cambyses." He seized the kingdom. | ||
"After that, Cambyses died." Perhaps he was murdered, likely by Darius and his cohorts. Darius and his cohorts probably murdered Bardiya also. |
||
"The people feared him [Gaumata] greatly, (thinking that) he would slay in numbers the people who previously had known Bardiya." ". . . lest they know me, that I am not Bardiya, the son of Cyrus." How many people have ever been able to recognize their rulers? People witnessed pomp and circumstance and trusted that the crowned figure was their king. | ||
"Nobody dared say anything about Gaumata . . . until I came." Perhaps because he was really Bardiya. | ||
"Then I, with a few men, slew that Gaumata, the Magian, and those who were his foremost followers." Likely, a coup d'état. The few men – Darius's cohorts. | ||
Note: | * Media – I prefer a novel spelling, Medîa, to distinguish between the country's name and the English word 'media'. I also prefer to pronounce this word 'Medîa' with the emphasis on the penultimate syllable – mee DEE ah. Similarly, I use a related spelling for the name of the ethnicity which is conventionally spelled 'Median' in English – Medîan, also with the emphasis on the penultimate syllable. (I am satisfied to use 'Mede' for the ethnicity, too.) Again, I am distinguishing between the ethnic name and the English word 'median'. However, on these pages with translations from Lendering and Peterson, I have not changed their spellings 'Media' and 'Median' and 'Medea' and 'Medean' respectively. |
The links on this page were checked in May 2009.
† Most or all pictures and images on this page have been retouched by Nathaniel Segal, which means digitally altered from their source versions.